Showing posts with label USW. Show all posts
Showing posts with label USW. Show all posts

Monday, September 24, 2012

No, the President Will Not Extend His Favorite Protectionist Tariffs This Week (Thank Goodness)

A couple weeks ago, I openly asked why, considering how much President Obama just loves the tariffs on Chinese tires that he imposed in 2009 under "Section 421" of US trade law, they were going to expire at the end of this month.  This morning, however, the Huffington Post's Jon Ward had some pretty reasonable-sounding speculation that Obama will, in fact, extend the tariffs before they expire this Wednesday, September 26th:
President Obama plans to travel to Ohio for campaign events on Wednesday, the same day that a three-year tariff on the import of Chinese tires is set to expire.

It's not likely that Obama will let that happen, especially on a day when he is in a major tire manufacturing state, a state that is key to victory in the fall election and where many voters blame China for a long list of economic ills...

On Monday, the Obama campaign again showed its sensitivity to any attacks on the president's record on China and responded immediately with a memo from national spokesman Ben LaBolt, who pointed to the multiple investments by Romney's fund managers in Chinese companies and to the number of trade complaints brought by the administration at the WTO.

But LaBolt also mentioned the tire tariff, calling it "aggressive action against China on behalf of American tire workers."

"When he visits Toledo this week, those tire workers will welcome Romney to remind him that when it mattered most, President Obama stood up for them and he turned his back on them," LaBolt wrote.

The Huffington Post asked LaBolt last week about the tire tariff's pending expiration, but the normally responsive spokesman did not have anything to say about it. A White House spokeswoman on Monday morning also did not return an email requesting comment...

[W]ith the president headed to Ohio and the tire tariff now a gambit in the campaign, as each candidate bills himself as the most committed to "stand up to China," as the Romney campaign puts it, it seems likely that Obama is planning to announce an extension of the tariff at his campaign events in Bowling Green and Kent.
When I read Ward's blog post this morning and then saw this new Obama Campaign ad bragging about the tire tariffs (and bashing Romney's wise opposition to them), I admit that I was pretty concerned that my previous analysis of the legal basis for extending the tire tariffs was wrong.  However, after re-reading that analysis a few times and reassuring myself that the President had absolutely no legal authority to extend the tariffs at this late stage, I then became concerned that the White House was simply preparing to ignore the law's plain text.  (It wouldn't be the first time they've ignored the law on a China-related matter, and what journalist is knowledgeable enough - or willing - to call them on it?)  It turns out, however, that my concerns were misguided.  Shortly after noon today, Ward updated his earlier blog post with the following news from the White House and others:
UPDATE: 12:36 p.m. -- A White House official said Monday that the tire tariff will in fact expire, because the United Steelworkers felt that the provision had had the intended effect.

LaBolt, Obama's campaign spokesman, said in an email that "the President's action achieved its goals of saving 1,000 jobs and protecting American businesses against a surge of Chinese tires."

UPDATE: 1:30 p.m. -- A senior Romney adviser, asked Monday whether the tariff should be allowed to expire or not, did not directly answer....

The tariff's expiration on the day that Obama arrives in Ohio may sound an off-note; but if the tariff's primary beneficiary, USW -- which has not requested an extension, according to the White House -- is on board, criticism of the president is likely to be minimal.

UPDATE: 1:47 p.m. -- United Steelworkers President Leo Gerard said in an emailed statement that the organization informed the administration in March that it would not request an extension of the tariff.

"Since [Obama's] decision, by every measure, success has been achieved: jobs have been retained and created, production has rebounded, investments in plant and equipment have been made and many companies have returned to profitability. That’s why the law was enacted, and it worked," said Gerard.

The USW added that "under an unacceptable, but existing provision of international trade law, compensation for a fourth year of relief might have had to be paid to China."

"We refused to pursue an option that could potentially reward China for their actions," Gerard said.

The Wall Street Journal reported in January, however, that the impact of the tariff was negligible because low cost tires started coming into the U.S. from other foreign countries.
And, of course, the tariffs cost at least $900k/per union job allegedly saved - but hey, that's "mission accomplished" according to Leo Gerard.  Nice work, dude.  Way to go.

But I digress.

So, as I originally reported, it looks like we'll finally be rid of the tire tariffs this week after all.  That's certainly great news for American businesses and consumers, huge protectionist costs notwithstanding.  However, I now am left wondering what President Obama has up his sleeve when he visits Ohio on the day that the tariffs expire.  Another WTO case maybe?  Something else?  Shudder to think.

We'll know soon enough, I guess.

Monday, February 13, 2012

Everything You Need to Know About Obama's Trade "Enforcement" Budget (and the Political Problems with Romney's China Trade Plan)

President Obama officially released his 2012 budget today, and, as expected, it proposes significant new funds for the super-duper trade enforcement team - the "Interagency Trade Enforcement Center" - that he outlined during his recent State of the Union Address.  Because the substance and future of both the President's budget and the ITEC is in serious doubt (as I've already noted), it's probably a waste of time to spend too much virtual ink on the proposals and their implications.  But just in case you're just dying for commentary, here's all you really need to know about the whether the proposed agency is a good or bad thing for US trade policy (and what "enforcement" really means): the President's plan is strongly supported by the vehemently anti-trade United Steelworkers Union (USW).  In fact, USW President Leo Gerard issued a lengthy press release lauding the plan:
President Obama has acted to enforce America's laws against unfair trade since coming to office and announced in his State of the Union address last month, a clear commitment to this effort. The USW is especially pleased to know the President's budget will be asking for millions of dollars to arm his new Interagency Trade Enforcement Center (ITEC) with the resources needed to fight for American jobs.

Too many American workers have had their jobs stolen from them by foreign unfair, predatory and illegal trade practices. Many of our trade competitors agree to the rules, but then fail to abide by them. Enforcing our laws – and the commitments other countries have made – must be high priority. President Obama is devoting resources to accomplish that goal....

In his State of the Union message, the President highlighted the success of the trade case brought by the Steelworkers against a flood of tire imports from China that had been decimating employment here. His leadership has helped to return the industry to stability, put American tire builders back to work and has stimulated the expansion of production and investment here at home. His efforts deserve, and have, our sincere gratitude.
Yes, yes, the President's Chinese tire and other trade remedies efforts just might deserve, and have, the union's sincere gratitude, but, as I've repeatedly noted here, they - or, more accurately, the skyrocketing prices, injured retailers and consumers, rampant trade diversion and economic uncertainty that they created - certainly deserve everyone else's extreme ridicule and disdain.  And if the USW's anti-trade policy and the Chinese tire tariffs are an indication of what President Obama's new budget is going to buy us (on credit!), then we once again can be thankful that the plan won't be carried out.

Beyond helping us understand the true intent of President Obama's "enforcement" plans, the USW press release also provides further proof that placating anti-traders with token acts or promises of protectionism is a fool's errand, especially for Republican politicians.  After Gerard finished praising the President for his commitment to painful protectionism enforcement, he then lays into GOP hopeful Mitt Romney, alleging that  "[t]his President's budget makes an important investment in trade law. The Republican candidate, Mitt Romney, would jeopardize our successes and reverse course on enforcing the rules."  Gerard then spends a couple paragraphs hitting Romney - who, by the way, is campaigning in Michigan right now - for his views on the China tires case and the auto bailouts.

Yet never once does Gerard - who literally just finished praising President Obama's aggressive China protectionism - heap similar praise onto Romney for his even more aggressive stance on China trade and currency (a stance that even Obama won't take).  Now, I certainly think that Romney's China currency stance is misguided from a legal, moral and economic perspective, but some pro-Romney cynics have argued that, those fair criticisms aside, his policy is smart politics because it will attract votes and support in heavily-unionized swing states like Ohio, Pennsylvania and, yes, Michigan.  I disagreed with such political calculations (and continue to do so), and Gerard's statements provide support for my view that Romney's China trade plans are not only bad policy, but also bad politics.

Protectionists will just never - ever - be placated with token protectionism (especially when it's a Republican politician doing the placating).

Now, leaving the USW and other professional protectionists aside, Romney's China currency plan is already revealing another big political flaw: the policy's economic and legal failings undermine much-deserved criticism of Obama's very bad record on trade policy (another problem I noted a few months back).   Indeed, just a few days ago, NYU law professor Robert Howse dismissed a very good op-ed by Columbia's Jagdish Bhagwati that absolutely destroyed Obama's latest trade pandering.  Howse did so not by addressing the substance of Bhagwati's claims, but instead by simply pointing to Romney's even worse stance on China trade.  I'm quite sure that if Romney's the nominee, we can expect similar diversions from Obama supporters between now and November.  And considering just how bad President Obama's trade policy has been over the last few years, it's a real shame that the likely Republican standard-bearer won't be able to mount an effective, full-throated criticism.

Sounds depressingly familiar, now that I think of it.  Sigh.